Carlton Musical Productions has won several NODA awards for its productions.
2007
Winner 2007 East Midlands Region - Best District Production for Best Musical (in District 3)
2009
Winner 2009 East Midlands Region - Best District Production for Best Musical (in District 3).
Winner Hinks-Cole Trophy for Best Production
Presented on 10th May 2010 at Loughborough Town Hall.
2014
Winner 2014 East Midlands Region - Best District Production for Best Musical (in District 3)
Presented on 14th June 2015 at Loughborough Town Hall.
2015
Nominated for 2015 East Midlands Region - Best District Production for Best Musical (in District 3)
Nominated for 2015 East Midlands Region - Hinks-Cole Trophy for Best Production
2016
Winner 2016 East Midlands Region - Hinks-Cole Trophy for Best Production
Nominated for 2016 East Midlands Region - Best District Production for Best Musical (in District 3)
Presented on 11th June 2017 at Loughborough Town Hall.
2017
Winner 2017 East Midlands - Tailby Trophy for Best Production in the East Midlands area.
Nominated for 2017 East Midlands Region - Best District Production for Best Musical (in District 3)
Presented on 10th June 2018 at Loughborough Town Hall.
2018
Nominated for 2018 East Midlands - Best District Production for Best Musical (in District 3)
2019
Winner East Midlands - Deluxe Programme - awarded 21st April 2020, and carried forward to the National competition.
Winner National - Owen Peacock Trophy - Deluxe Programme - awarded 19th September 2020.
2022
Winner 2022 East Midlands District 3 - Best Musical.
Presented 21st May 2023 in Melton Mowbray.
2023
Winner East Midlands - Deluxe Programme. Presented on 9th June 2024 in Melton Mowbray, and carried forward to the National competition.
2024
Winner Hinks-Cole Trophy for Best Musical in East Midlands Region
Winner Best Musical, District 3
Winner Lu Anthony, Outstanding Individual Performance, District 3
Nominations for Sarah Thompson for Outstanding Individual Performance and Jonathan Jaycock for Outstanding Youth Individual Performance, and for Best Peacock Class (Deluxe) Program in the East Midlands Region.
Results announced on Sunday 22nd June 2025 at Concordia Theatre, Hinckley